What Trading at Auction Costs in Forever
Selling through the auction house is not free, and the money leaves your purse in three separate places. One charge is paid for the act of posting, one is held against goods that do not move, and one is taken out of the payment when they do. This is how those three sit next to each other, what changed on the beta, and which part of it we still cannot describe.
Three charges sit on one sale
A completed auction is not a single payment. There is a charge for putting the lot up, a deposit held while the lot sits on the shelf, and a cut taken out of the coin when a buyer pays. Most players only notice the last of the three, because it is the only one that shows up while money is arriving. The other two are paid in advance, on every attempt, whether or not anybody opens the listing at all.
The timing matters more than the size of any one charge. Posting costs are spent before the market has told you anything, so a seller who relists the same goods through several undercut rounds pays for each round separately. the cut taken on a completed sale only applies once, at the end, and only if the sale happens. A shelf full of stubborn stock therefore costs money quietly, in small amounts, over as many postings as the seller is willing to make.
For a gatherer this is a rounding error on a stack of ore. For a crafter working through an inventory of slow-moving items it is a real line in the week's accounts, because the same pieces go back up again and again. That is why the coin held on an unsold lot is worth working out before a bench produces a batch rather than after it fails to clear.
The per-lot charge came down
On the beta the flat charge for posting a lot was reduced from 1 silver to 1 copper. That sounds like housekeeping and for one stack of herbs it is. It stops being housekeeping for anyone whose selling pattern is many small lots rather than a few large ones: single crafted items, odd greens off a levelling route, one-of-a-kind recipes and leftovers from a vendor run. Under the old charge each of those cost something to merely try.
The second group it touches is anyone who cancels and reposts to stay on top of the sort order. Each cycle used to carry the full posting charge, which put a quiet floor under how often undercutting was worth doing. With the charge at a copper, the constraint on repostings is mostly the deposit and the player's patience, not the fee, and reposting against an undercut is decided on different arithmetic than it was earlier in testing.
What the change does not do is make selling free. The deposit is the larger of the two up-front costs on most goods, and it is unaffected by this edit. Anyone reading the lower fee as a green light to spam single-item listings will still be paying the held coin on every one of them.
Deposits are charged on the stack
The deposit is held per lot, not per item, and that is the part sellers most often get backwards. Splitting 1 stack into separate single listings means a separate deposit on each of them. Posting the same goods as one stack means paying once. The split can still be correct when buyers want small quantities, but it is a decision with a price attached, and the price is paid at posting rather than out of the proceeds.
Duration works the same way: a longer listing holds more coin for longer. The money comes back when the lot sells, and it does not come back when the seller cancels, which makes cancelling an expensive habit on high-value goods. working out the deposit in advance is the difference between a crafter who knows what a batch costs to list and one who finds out after the third repost.
Practically, this pushes sellers toward fewer, larger lots on commodity materials and toward careful duration choices on anything slow. It also rewards knowing roughly what a vendor would pay for the item, since the held amount tracks that value rather than the price you hope to get.
The purchase limit, and what we cannot describe
Alongside the fee edit, beta reports mention a limit on buying through the auction house. We have not seen the terms of it published: not what it counts, not whether it applies per character or per account, and not whether it is a testing measure or an intended rule. Because of that we are not going to describe how it behaves or how to work around it. When there is something official attached to it, this section gets rewritten rather than padded out with guesses.
Two more things are genuinely open. The first is whether the cut on completed sales is the same across every category of goods or varies by item type. The second is whether the lowered posting charge survives into live realms at all, since beta edits are reverted as often as they are kept. Neither has a published figure behind it, and we are not inventing one.
What is safe to plan around is the shape rather than the amounts: pay something to post, hold something while waiting, give up something on the sale. how the auction house handles listings is the part that decides how often those three charges land on the same goods.
Questions
Is the deposit refunded when an item sells?
Yes. The held coin comes back to the seller on a completed sale, which is why the deposit is a cost of failure rather than a cost of trading. It is not returned when the seller cancels the listing, so cancelling a high-value lot to reprice it is the one case where the deposit behaves like a straight loss.
Does the lower posting charge make undercutting free?
No. It removes one of the two up-front costs on a repost, but the deposit is charged again on each new listing and is usually the larger of the two. Frequent repricing is now limited by held coin and time rather than by the flat fee, which is a different constraint, not an absent one.
Is it cheaper to post one stack or several single lots?
One stack is cheaper, because the deposit is held per lot. Splitting goods into single listings multiplies both the deposit and the posting charge. The split can still be worth it when buyers only want small quantities and pay a premium for them, but the extra cost is paid at posting whether or not that premium turns up.
How many items can one character buy at auction?
We cannot answer that. Beta reports mention a limit on purchases, but we have not seen the terms of it published, so we do not know what it counts or whether it applies per character or per account. We would rather leave the question open than describe a rule we have not read.
Sources
- Blizzard's news and patch note archive, where auction house changes are written up when they leave testing — World of Warcraft news archive.
- The official forums, where the beta reports on posting charges and purchase limits are being posted and argued over — World of Warcraft forums.