Bag Space Is a Running Cost
Nobody lists bag slots next to training fees and reagents, but they behave like a bill all the same. Stacks of 20, containers bought once per character, and the class items that occupy space before a single coin is earned decide how long a route runs and how much of it reaches a mailbox.
Stacks of 20 set the length of a route
Trade goods move in stacks of 20 on a Classic ruleset, and that number, rather than the clock, is what ends a gathering run. A mixed route does not fill 1 slot at a time; it fills several at once, because copper and tin are separate items, and so are 2 herbs taken from neighbouring nodes. The bag runs out of room while every stack inside it is still half empty. From there the choice is to ride back and empty it or to keep gathering and throw something away, and travel time between nodes is charged either way.
Skinning makes the same problem worse, because a route that produces leather also produces scraps, and the 2 of them do not combine. Grey loot competes for the remaining slots against goods that other players actually want. The usual rule of thumb is to keep whatever sells to a player and drop whatever sells to a merchant, but that only works if you know which is which, and merchant prices on grey loot are the part most people guess at instead of checking.
None of this shows up as a loss anywhere a player can see. It shows up as a shorter route, an extra ride, or a stack left on the ground, which is why it is worth counting the same way as fuel rather than as an inconvenience. A route measured against gold per hour after logistics looks different once the emptying trips are inside the number instead of outside it.
Bags are bought once per character and paid for every time
A bag is one of the few purchases that returns nothing directly. It sells no item, buffs nothing and adds no stat. What it does is lengthen the stretch between 2 trips to a mailbox, which is why gatherers buy them early and everyone else buys them late. The supply comes from tailors, from drops and from merchants, and the asking price moves with how many tailors on the realm have levelled far enough, which is the whole of bags sold at auction in one sentence.
The bill repeats per character rather than per account. A new alt starts with the same problem the main had, which is why what a new alt costs to equip usually includes containers before it includes gear. A character kept purely to hold stock has the same requirement at a larger scale, and a bank alt holding stock is mostly an argument about how many containers one account is willing to fund.
Bank slots sit on the other side of the same decision. Storage bought at the bank is paid in coin and never travels with you; storage bought as bags travels but is limited by what the character can carry. Materials waiting for a price are the usual reason either one gets expanded, and storage for profession materials is the part of a crafting business that produces no income while it runs.
Ammunition and shards take space nobody refunds
Some classes pay the inventory bill twice. A hunter carries ammunition that is spent shot by shot and has to be restocked before a run rather than after it, and the dedicated container that holds it holds nothing else, so it does not solve the general space problem. The restocking side of that is already counted in ammunition, reagents and poisons, and the storage side of it is the same bill arriving in a different form.
Warlocks carry the opposite problem: shards are not bought, they accumulate. Each one occupies a slot until it is used, and a long evening of summons and soulstones produces more of them than a general-purpose bag is comfortable holding. Classes that cast from reagents are in the middle of those 2 cases, paying a vendor for stock that then has to be carried. What that adds up to over a week belongs with upkeep charged by class rather than with gear.
The practical effect is that 2 characters doing the same route do not come home with the same amount of sellable goods. The one carrying class items started with fewer free slots, and that difference is permanent rather than occasional.
What we do not know about Forever yet
We have not seen anything confirming that Forever changes stack sizes, container sizes or bank capacity, and we are not going to assume either direction. The profession rework has been described in detail while storage has not been described at all, which is not the same as a statement that storage is untouched. Until that is written down somewhere official, treat 20 as the working number and treat everything about bag sizes as unverified.
The same caution applies to anything account-wide. Whether items can be moved between characters without a trip across the map is a storage question as much as a logistics one, and mail and account storage rules covers what is actually known rather than what players expect from Retail. Holding times matter for the same reason, because a mailbox used as overflow storage is only useful for as long as it keeps the item.
Questions
Do bigger bags actually make more gold?
Not directly. A bag sells nothing and buffs nothing. It changes how long a route runs before a trip back, so the return shows up as fewer interruptions rather than as income, and it is largest for gathering characters who fill slots quickly with heavy stacks.
Why does a route fill up with half-empty stacks?
Because stacking only works within the same item. Copper and tin, or two different herbs, occupy separate slots regardless of how few of each you are carrying, so a mixed route uses far more slots than the total count of items would suggest.
Should grey loot be picked up at all?
It depends on what else the route produces. If the bag is not filling, grey loot is free coin on the way to the merchant. If the bag fills before the route ends, every grey item is a slot taken from something a player would have paid more for.
Has Forever changed stack sizes or bag sizes?
We have no confirmation either way. Blizzard has gone into detail on professions and said nothing we have seen about storage, so the honest answer is that it is unverified and should be checked on a live realm rather than assumed from other Classic versions.
Sources
- Blizzard's official site for World of Warcraft and the Classic line, used for anything described as confirmed — World of Warcraft official site.
- Item database used to check stack sizes and container types on a Classic ruleset — Wowhead.