How the Auction House Works in Forever
The auction house is where most gold in Forever changes hands, so the rules of the shelf itself matter as much as what you farm. Three of them decide almost everything: how far a listing reaches, what the deposit costs before a buyer appears, and how far the auction price sits above what a vendor would pay.
Who a listing actually reaches
The first thing that decides whether a stack sells is how many people can open the shelf it sits on. In the Classic line an auction house belongs to a faction: the houses in the capitals are shopped by one side of the war, and the neutral houses run by goblins are the only shelves both sides use, on worse terms for the seller. Forever has not described a different arrangement, so treat that as the inherited model rather than a confirmed Forever feature.
Reach also stops at borders that have nothing to do with factions. Whether realms shop from one shelf decides whether you are undercutting a handful of sellers or a crowd, and realms sharing one auction house is the setting that moves a price further than any farming route does. The same question runs above that one, because separate markets in each region never trade with each other at all, whatever the realm list looks like inside one of them.
Faction size is the quieter half of reach. A seller on the crowded side has more buyers and more competitors for the same slot, while the smaller side has thin supply and thin demand at once, which usually shows up as wider gaps between listings rather than as higher prices. How a lopsided faction split lands on a given realm is worth checking before deciding that a trade is unprofitable.
The deposit is charged before anything sells
Posting is not free. The auction house takes a deposit when the lot goes up, holds it while the listing runs, and returns it when the item sells. If the listing expires, or if you pull it down early, the deposit stays with the house. That makes posting a bet rather than a display: the gold leaves your purse at the moment you click, and nothing about a buyer existing has been established yet.
The size of that deposit is not drawn from the auction price you set. It is worked out from what a vendor would pay for the item and from how long the listing is meant to run, so a long posting of a bulky, vendor-valuable stack locks up far more than a short posting of something a vendor barely wants. Both halves of that are worth knowing in advance: what a vendor pays for an item sets the base, and working out a listing deposit turns it into a figure you can plan around.
The cost compounds when a market is busy. Every time you cancel a lot to undercut someone, the deposit on the cancelled listing is gone and a fresh one is charged on the replacement, which is why cancelling to undercut a rival can quietly eat the margin it was meant to protect. On cheap goods the charge behaves like a floor under what is worth posting at all, and the smallest lot worth listing is a different number for every trade.
The spread to vendor price decides what to post
Every item has a guaranteed buyer who never haggles: the vendor. That price is the floor under the whole market, because nobody sells at auction for less than a merchant would hand over on the spot. The useful number is the gap between the two. Take the auction price, subtract the cut the house takes on a sale and the deposit you risk getting back, and compare what is left with the vendor price. If the gap is small, the vendor wins on time alone.
That is also why the cut taken from a completed sale belongs in the calculation before the listing goes up rather than after it clears. Goods with a wide spread are the ones players cannot get from a merchant at all: raid consumables, trade materials, recipes and gear that fills a slot nobody else supplies. Goods with a thin spread are the ones a vendor already prices generously, and posting those is usually paying a deposit for the privilege of waiting.
The gap runs in the other direction too. When a crafted item is worth more to a merchant than its materials cost on the shelf, the trade is no longer about buyers at all, and crafting goods for vendor value turns the floor into an income source. The same logic sits behind buying cheap lots to vendor, where the entire margin comes from someone else mispricing the floor.
What is not settled yet
We are not going to print exact deposit rates, cut rates or listing durations for Forever, because we have not seen them published for Forever specifically. The Classic line behaves the way described above, and nothing in the material we have read says the model changed, but a model and a rate are different things. If Blizzard states the figures, or if the beta client makes them readable in a way that is not guesswork, we will write them down and mark where they came from.
Two further things are open. Whether the posting window itself has been reworked matters to anyone listing in bulk, and the posting window and its controls is the part of the client most likely to change between a beta build and 4 November. Availability is the other: a shelf that is unreachable is a shelf that cannot refund a deposit on time, and the auction house being offline has already shaped how carefully people time long listings.
Questions
Is the deposit refunded if my item sells?
Yes. In the Classic model the deposit is held while the listing runs and returned to you when a buyer completes the purchase. It is kept by the auction house if the listing expires unsold, and it is also kept if you cancel the lot yourself before it runs out, which is the part that costs frequent undercutters the most.
Does the deposit depend on the price I ask?
No. It is worked out from the vendor value of the item and the length of the listing, not from your asking price. That is why posting a cheap stack at an ambitious price costs the same as posting it at a sensible one, and why bulky goods with a high merchant value are expensive to leave sitting on a long listing.
When should I sell to a vendor instead of posting?
When the auction price minus the house cut leaves little more than the merchant would pay, and when the item is something a merchant prices well anyway. Vendoring is instant, carries no deposit risk and no waiting. Posting is worth the charge only on goods a vendor cannot supply to other players in the first place.
Can both factions use the same auction house in Forever?
The Classic arrangement is that each faction has its own houses in its capitals, with neutral goblin-run houses as the only shared option and worse terms for the seller there. Forever has not been described as changing this. If that turns out to be wrong, it will be corrected here with a source attached rather than left as an assumption.
Sources
- Reference description of the deposit, cut and listing-duration model the Classic line inherits — Warcraft Wiki: Auction House.
- Official news hub, where any published change to auction rules would appear first — World of Warcraft news.