Camp Station Timers Decide What Gets Crafted
Most crafting plans are written as a shopping list: so many stacks in, one finished item out. On a realm where the best recipes need a camp station that is not always standing, the binding limit sits somewhere else. This is an argument about access as the scarce input, written with the parts we cannot confirm marked as such.
Access is the scarce input, not the reagent bill
A crafter reading a recipe list sees two costs: the materials and the skill points needed to reach the line. Both are solvable with coin or with hours. The third cost is harder to put a figure on, because it is not charged in either currency. A recipe that requires a camp station can only be run where that station is standing, while it is standing, and the stations listed by trade are the part of the system that decides when a bench is a bench and when it is just an inventory full of stacks.
That distinction matters because the two inputs respond to pressure in opposite ways. Reagent prices answer to gatherers: if a stack is expensive, more people farm it, and the shelf refills. Station access does not answer to anything a market can do. No amount of coin shortens a cooldown or keeps a station from going away, which means the materials cost of each craft can fall all year without a single extra item reaching a buyer.
Read that way, the top of a 300-skill recipe list is not a price problem. It is a scheduling problem, and the crafters who treat it as one end up with more finished stock than the ones who simply buy cheaper stacks.
A cooldown turns an order list into a queue
Crafting for other players normally works on a first-come basis: a buyer asks, the crafter checks the bags, the item is made and mailed. Put a cooldown between those steps and the same trade becomes a queue with a fixed throughput. Orders stop being independent jobs and start competing for the same slots, which is a different business even though nothing about the recipe changed. Anyone taking work from strangers in chat is really selling a position in that queue rather than selling an item.
The pricing follows. When the limit is materials, a crafter can quote a fee on top of the stacks and take every job offered. When the limit is slots, the fee has to ration demand instead of covering costs, and the usual rules for setting a commission on crafted goods stop fitting. Two buyers wanting the same cooldown on the same evening is the normal case, not the rare one.
It also changes who gets served. Guild members, regulars and anyone who supplies their own stacks move to the front simply because they are less work per slot, and that keeps a share of high-skill output off the open shelf entirely.
Despawn makes crafting a trip rather than a task
A station that disappears after a while is not the same object as an anvil in a capital. The anvil is a place you pass; the camp station is an appointment. Everything the crafter intends to make has to be in the bags before the station goes up, because a missing reagent means another gathering run and another setup, and the distance charged on every run is paid again rather than once. That is why experienced crafters batch: one setup, one list, everything at once.
Batching has a cost of its own. Holding stacks until there are enough of them to justify a session ties up bag space and delays sales, and the coin sits in materials instead of in the mailbox. The arithmetic of an hour spent at a camp only works if the session produces several finished items, which pushes crafters toward fewer, larger trips and away from making single pieces to order.
The visible result on the shelf is lumpy supply: nothing for a stretch, then a batch, then nothing again. That pattern comes from the timer, not from a shortage of anybody willing to farm.
What we cannot tell you about the timers
We do not have the numbers. We cannot tell you how long any station stays up, how long a cooldown runs between uses, whether the clock belongs to the station or to the character, or whether the rules are the same for every trade. We have no patch note setting those values and no beta log we would be willing to publish as fact. Anyone quoting exact durations on a forum is reporting what they saw on one build, which is a reasonable thing to read and a poor thing to budget against.
We also do not know whether a station can be shared, whether a second crafter standing at the same camp gets their own use, or what happens when a group sets up together. That question decides whether a camp is a private bench or a small shop, and the answer would change how the running cost of a camp is split between the people using it.
Until those details are settled, the safe reading is directional rather than numeric: access is tighter than materials at the top of a recipe list, and any comparison of gathering against crafting income that ignores station uptime is measuring only half the job.
Questions
Does a station cooldown really limit income, or just timing?
It limits income whenever demand is larger than the number of slots available. If a crafter could sell 3 items a day and the station allows fewer uses than that, the extra demand never becomes a sale, no matter how cheap the reagents are. If demand is below the slot count, the timer only affects when the gold arrives and not how much of it there is.
Can a crafter avoid the problem by using a city forge or anvil instead?
Only for the recipes that accept one. The whole point of a station-gated plan is that the ordinary city equipment does not satisfy it, so the lower part of a list stays available anywhere while the top of it does not. Which specific recipes are gated this way in Forever is not something we can list with confidence, and we are not going to guess at the breakdown.
How should a crafter quote a job that depends on a station?
Quote the slot, not the item. Tell the buyer when the next session is, ask them to supply reagents if they want to move up the list, and do not promise same-evening delivery for a recipe that needs a setup. Most disputes over commission work come from a buyer assuming an item is made on demand when the crafter is actually waiting on a timer.
Does this change which professions are worth taking?
It changes the comparison, not necessarily the answer. A gathering route produces output in proportion to the hours put in, while a station-gated craft produces output in proportion to the sessions a player can schedule. Someone who plays in short irregular blocks gets more from gathering; someone who can plan one long session gets more from a bench that batches well.
Sources
- Blizzard's own news channel for World of Warcraft, where camping and the profession rework were introduced — World of Warcraft news.