Picking a Centaur Clan Locks Your Recipes
Desolace holds two centaur clans, Gelkis and Magram, and standing with one is earned by killing the other. The quartermasters at the two camps do not stock the same plans, so the grind a character does there decides what that crafter can ever offer. This is what the choice costs and why the split shows up in prices.
The choice is made with kills, not with a dialogue box
Nothing about the centaur clans is picked from a menu. Standing with Gelkis rises as Magram centaurs die, and standing with Magram rises the same way in reverse. The two bars move against each other on the same character, so every hour spent earning access to one camp pushes the other further out of reach. The quartermaster only trades once the character is Friendly, which means the grind has to be finished before a single plan can be bought.
That is what makes it one-way in practice rather than in the rules. Switching sides does not start from zero: it starts from the hole the first grind dug, and the character has to climb out of it before climbing up the other side. Few people do that twice. The sensible answer is usually a second character, and splitting trades across alts is cheaper than reversing a reputation bar on the one that is already capped.
The bill is paid in hours rather than coin. Desolace is a long ride from most of the levelling route, the camps are spread apart, and the mobs do not respawn fast enough to make this a short session. Before committing a weekend to it, count the hours a detour costs against what the same evening would earn on a route the character already runs.
What the split does to supply
The interesting part is not the grind, it is what the grind does to a realm. Because the choice is per character and awkward to reverse, the crafters who can make a Gelkis plan and the crafters who can make a Magram one are two different groups, and both groups are smaller than the number of people with the trade maxed. A recipe behind that gate is scarce for a reason that has nothing to do with its materials.
That is why these items price oddly. The reagents may be ordinary, but how thin a shelf can get depends on how many sellers exist at all, and here the pool is cut roughly in half before anyone decides whether the item is worth listing. When the listing is empty, the trade moves into whispers instead, and an order placed with a crafter is how most of these pieces actually change hands.
Working out whether to join that group is ordinary arithmetic. Add the hours of the grind to what the materials cost per craft, then divide by the number of items the bench realistically sells in a month. A plan that two people on the realm can make is only valuable if somebody wants it; scarcity on its own has never paid anybody.
Who should pay the detour and who should skip it
If the bench exists to supply your own characters, the clan choice is close to irrelevant: take whichever camp is nearer the route you were already running and never think about it again. If the bench exists to take money from strangers, the choice is a product decision, and it belongs in the same conversation as which trade earns the most rather than being settled by whichever centaur you happened to kill first while questing.
It also sits in a wider pattern. Forever gates a noticeable share of its plans behind standing rather than behind trainers, so a crafter who ignores reputation ends up with the catalogue every other crafter has. The same logic runs through crates traded for recipe unlocks and through discounts earned through standing: the coin cost is small, and the real price is attention paid early rather than late.
Our reading, labelled as ours: do the grind once, on the character that takes orders, and leave the opposite clan for an alt if the second list ever starts selling. Doing both on one character is a way to spend a weekend and end up Friendly with nobody.
What we have not confirmed for Forever
Two things here are structure, not numbers, and we are keeping them separate. The mechanic described above is how the Desolace clans have always worked. Whether Forever leaves the two vendor lists exactly as they were, adds to them from the new recipe pool, or changes how standing is earned at those camps is not something we have seen stated, so we are not putting a list of plans on this page.
We are also not quoting reputation amounts, kill counts or vendor prices. Those have not been published for these realms, and the ones carried over from older versions are a guess dressed as a fact. If the clan vendors turn out to stock something the profession rework cares about, that belongs with what the supply side was changed into rather than in a figure invented here.
Questions
Can one character reach Friendly with both clans?
No. The two standings move in opposite directions on the same character, so raising one lowers the other. Reaching the vendor at both camps on a single character is not a matter of patience, it is a matter of undoing the work already done and then doing more of it in reverse.
Is the choice account-wide?
It is per character. An alt can take the opposite clan freely, which is why crafters who want both recipe lists usually put the second trade on a second character instead of trying to flip the bar back on the first one.
Does the split make these recipes more profitable?
It makes them scarcer, which is not the same thing. Fewer crafters can produce the item, but the price still depends on whether anyone wants it. A gated plan for a popular item can carry a bench; a gated plan for something nobody equips just means you spent a weekend in Desolace.
Has Forever changed what the clan quartermasters sell?
We have not seen that confirmed either way. The profession rework touched a lot of recipe lists, but nothing published that we know of says what happened to these two vendors specifically, so we are not listing their stock or guessing at new additions.
Sources
- Zone entry for Desolace with the two clan camps and their quartermasters — Wowhead Classic: Desolace.
- Where Blizzard posts profession and reputation changes for the Classic line — World of Warcraft news.