What a Bag Slot Costs in Forever
Bags get bought on every character, on every alt, and again whenever a gathering route outgrows the pack a player started with. That makes them one of the few crafted goods with demand that never goes quiet. This is how to price one honestly, by the slot rather than by the bag.
Price the slot, not the bag
A bag is not a single item with a single price. It is a container of slots, and the only comparison that survives between two different recipes is what one slot costs. Divide the full cost of making or buying a bag by the number of slots it holds, and two listings that looked unrelated line up next to each other. A smaller bag made from cheap reagents can beat a larger one that nobody can afford to supply, and the arithmetic says so before the listing does.
That same division is what tells a gatherer when to stop upgrading. Each extra slot buys a little more time on the route before the ride back to a mailbox, and the value of that time is not fixed: it depends on how far the nearest bank sits from the node cluster. The cost of the detour is the other half of the sum, and time spent on the road is what the extra slot is being measured against.
What the 11 November hotfix changed
On 11 November a hotfix touched 4 bag recipes, and it moved two things at once: the materials each one consumes and the number of slots the finished bag holds. Either change alone would have shifted the cost per slot. Both together mean that any arithmetic worked out before that date is stale, including arithmetic a crafter wrote down for their own reference. The recipe that was the cheapest supplier of slots on a realm may no longer be, and the one that nobody bothered with may now be worth the trainer visit.
The practical effect falls on crafters holding reagent stock. Materials bought for one plan do not automatically fit the edited version of it, and a bench that stocked ahead is now holding goods for a recipe that wants a different list. Working out whether to craft through the stock or sell it raw is the same calculation as any other, and what the materials cost to replace decides which side of it is cheaper.
Buyers notice later than crafters do. A bag listed before the hotfix and a bag listed after it can hold different numbers of slots under the same item name, so the first few days of a change like this are the ones where a careless comparison costs the most.
The free Faire bag sets a floor
Next to the crafted market sits a bag handed out for tickets at the Darkmoon Faire, holding 14 slots and costing no coin at all. That single item sets a floor under the whole lower end of the bag market: no crafted bag at or below that capacity has a serious audience while the faire is in town, because the alternative is free to anyone willing to hand in goods. A crafter who ignores the faire calendar will list into a week where the cheap end has no buyers.
Free is not the same as costless. The tickets come from turn-ins, and the goods handed in had to be made or bought first, which is the part most players leave out of the comparison. Whether the bag is genuinely cheaper than crafting one depends on what those turn-ins consumed, and what a faire week returns is the count that answers it. For a player with no crafting trade and spare materials in the bank, the answer is usually yes.
What we have not been able to pin down
We are not naming the 4 recipes the hotfix touched, because we have not seen a list we would stand behind, and guessing at recipe names is worse than saying nothing. We also do not know whether the capacity changes were upward, downward, or a mix, nor whether the team intends further passes on the same list. If that is published we will record it in the history block below rather than quietly editing the text.
Two other things are outside what we can state. We do not have vendor prices for any bag sold by an NPC on these realms, and we do not publish auction prices anywhere on the site, so nothing here turns into a number that goes out of date. What we can describe is the method: cost per slot, measured against the route it serves. The wider shelf behind it is covered in who supplies bags on a realm, and the carrying limit itself in stack size against bag slots.
Questions
How do I compare two bags with different sizes?
Divide what each one costs you, in materials or in coin, by the number of slots it holds, and compare those two figures. A bag is only worth more than a smaller one if its cost per slot is lower or if the saved bag space itself is worth something to you, which it usually is for a gatherer running long routes away from a bank.
Did the 11 November hotfix make bags cheaper or more expensive?
We cannot say in one direction. The hotfix changed both the material lists and the capacities of 4 recipes, and those two edits push cost per slot opposite ways. The honest answer is that any figure worked out before that date needs redoing with the current recipe in front of you rather than from memory.
Is the free Darkmoon Faire bag worth taking?
For most players, yes, especially on an alt that has nothing in its bags worth protecting. It holds 14 slots and costs tickets rather than coin. The qualifier is that tickets come from turn-ins, so the goods you hand in are the real price, and a crafter who could sell those goods instead should check which side is larger.
Should a crafter still train bag recipes after the change?
That depends on which recipes a realm already has covered. Bags have steady demand because every new character and every new alt needs them, but the cheapest supplier of slots takes most of the volume. Work out the cost per slot of the plans you can actually make, then look at what is already listed before paying a trainer.
Sources
- Blizzard publishes hotfix notes for live realms, which is where recipe and capacity changes of this kind are recorded — World of Warcraft news and hotfixes.