World of Warcraft: Forever launches November 4, 2026 — rates below are launch-day rates, nothing is on sale yet

WoW Forever Gold → Guides → Crafting cost

Guide · the supply side

Why Crafting Can Cost More Than It Returns

A bench can run all evening and still end the night poorer than it started. Three separate mechanisms do that, and they are usually blamed on one another: the fixed price a merchant pays, the deposit charged on the attempt to sell, and the stock made only to raise a skill.

The merchant price is fixed, the reagent price is not

Every item in the game carries an internal value, and that value is what a merchant hands over. It does not move when the realm wants more of the reagents inside the item. Reagents, by contrast, are priced by whoever is gathering that week. So the two halves of the arithmetic answer to different authorities: the product to a table written before the realm opened, the inputs to a shelf argued over every evening by players who can see each other's listings.

That is why an item can be worth less at a counter than the stack that made it, with nobody doing anything wrong. A crafter who sells to a merchant is accepting a known number and skipping the search for a buyer, which is a trade worth making for some recipes and ruinous for others. Which side a given recipe falls on is a per-item question, and what merchants pay for goods is the first figure to check before a plan is run in volume.

The gap widens whenever a reagent is also wanted by a different trade. Two benches bidding for the same herb or hide pushes the input price up while the merchant price stays exactly where it was. Nothing about the recipe changed; the competition for its materials did, and margins on vendor-sold crafts close from the input side rather than the output side.

The deposit is charged on the attempt

A listing is not free, and the charge comes before anyone decides whether to buy. The deposit is taken when the lot goes up, held for the duration, and lost if the lot expires unsold. A crafter who posts the same batch repeatedly pays it repeatedly, so the real cost of selling a slow item is the reagents plus every failed attempt that came before the successful one. Most people count only the attempt that worked.

Because the deposit follows the same internal value as the merchant price, cheap crafted goods are cheap to post and expensive ones are not. That makes the low end of a recipe list look safer than it is: the deposit is small, but so is the margin, and a handful of relists can eat the whole difference. Working the charge out in advance is ordinary bookkeeping, and how a deposit is calculated turns an unpleasant surprise into a line in the plan.

On top of the deposit sits the cut taken when the sale completes. The two are charged at different moments, which is what makes them easy to forget separately, and the fees charged on a sale should be subtracted before a batch is called profitable.

Skill points are bought with finished stock

The third mechanism is not a pricing problem at all. Raising a trade means producing items for the point rather than for a buyer, and most of what comes off the bench in that stretch is made because it still gives skill, not because the realm wants it. Those reagents are tuition. Counting them against the income of the finished career makes the career look worse than it is, and counting them as stock makes the shelf look fuller than it is.

The levelling window also has a crowd in it. Everyone pushing the same trade is producing the same intermediate items at roughly the same time, so the shelf receives a wave of identical goods from people who only wanted the point. The sensible reading is that those items were never meant to sell, and reagents burned on skill points belong in the setup column next to the trainer fee.

Treated that way, the loss stops being mysterious. The training run has a total, the career afterwards has a margin, and the two are separate accounts. Whether the second ever pays back the first depends on the trade, and the bill for raising a profession is the figure that decides which bench an alt should carry.

What we are not going to guess at

We are not publishing item values, deposit amounts or reagent prices here. The internal values are per-item and readable in the game, the deposit follows from them, and reagent prices move by realm and by week. Any figure we printed would be wrong for somebody reading it later, and a wrong figure is worse than none when the whole point is to compare three costs against each other.

Some of the detail is also simply not settled publicly. Which crafted items Forever has repriced relative to older versions, and whether merchant values get edited after launch, is not something we can state from an announcement. Where a number matters, check it on your own realm and on your own shelf; the method above holds whatever the figures turn out to be, and what reagents cost per craft is the input most likely to have moved since the last time you looked.

Questions

Why would a crafted item sell to a merchant for less than its reagents?

Because the two prices are set by different systems. The merchant pays a fixed internal value written into the item, while the reagents are priced by players competing for them. When demand for a material rises, the input cost rises and the merchant price does not move at all, so the gap can invert without anything in the recipe changing.

Does the deposit count as part of the cost of a craft?

Yes, and it counts once per attempt rather than once per sale. The deposit is taken when the lot is posted and lost if the lot expires, so an item that took several postings to move has carried several deposits. The honest cost basis is reagents plus every deposit paid along the way, with the sale cut subtracted at the end.

Should I count skill-up materials against my crafting income?

Keep them in a separate account. Items made purely for skill points were never intended for a buyer, so folding their reagents into the margin of the finished career makes that career look unprofitable when it is not. Treat the levelling run as a one-off setup cost, like the trainer fee, and judge the bench on what it earns afterwards.

Is selling to a merchant ever the right choice?

For some recipes it is. A merchant pays a known amount immediately, with no deposit, no waiting and no undercutting, which suits goods that have no steady buyer on the shelf. It is the wrong choice whenever the reagents inside the item are worth more raw, which is why the comparison has to be made recipe by recipe rather than once for the whole trade.

Sources

  • Blizzard's official World of Warcraft news feed, where profession notes and hotfixes are published — World of Warcraft news.