Hard Reserve Lists Replaced Dungeon Auctions
When gold auctions came off the table, the organising habit behind them did not disappear. It moved one step across: instead of selling a drop to the highest bidder, the organiser names the drop before the invite goes out and keeps it. This is how that arrangement works in Forever dungeons, what tends to end up on the list, and which parts of it nobody has a confirmed answer for.
A reserve is a loot rule, not a sale
A gold auction had two halves: a stated loot rule and a payment. The payment is what the GDKP ban in Forever removed, and the stated loot rule is what organisers kept. Under hard reserve the advert names specific items in advance, those items go to the organiser or to a named player when they drop, and everything else is rolled for by the group as normal. No coin moves between the people in the run, before it or after it.
The reason it took over so quickly is that a pug needs an answer to one question before strangers accept an invite: who gets the good drop. A reserve answers it in a single line of text, which is why it reads like an advert rather than a negotiation. Everything outside the named items falls back to whatever group loot settings in dungeons the leader has set, so the rest of the run behaves like any other pug.
The arrangement is social rather than mechanical. Nothing in the client enforces a reserve; the organiser holds master loot or simply trusts the group, and the agreement is worth as much as the reputation of the person who posted it. That is a real difference from an auction, where the gold changed hands at the end of the run and settled the matter.
What ends up on a reserve list
Reserve lists are shorter than old auction lists, because an auction could price every drop and a reserve has to be worth organising a run for. In practice the named items are the ones with a buyer outside the group: blue weapons and trinkets that sit on the pre-raid BiS list, recipes that unlock a profession branch, and the occasional BoE that can be posted instead of worn. Everything else is cheaper to roll for than to argue about.
Two shapes of list are common. In the first, the organiser reserves the sellable items and invites the rest of the group for free, which means the run is paid for in loot rather than in coin, and the payout only arrives once the item is listed. In the second, a guild or a fixed group reserves an upgrade for a named member and fills the remaining slots from chat, which is closer to guild loot kept for members than to a service.
What we cannot give is a ranking. We have no count of how often any specific item appears on a reserve line, no record of which dungeons carry the longest lists, and no figures for how much of a bench's stock arrives this way. Anything in that direction would be a guess dressed as data.
Where the rules sit, and what is not stated
The ban is written about gold auctions in group content: items sold to bidders, coin split among the participants. A plain hard reserve has no payment leg at all, so there is nothing to bid on and nothing to split. That is how organisers read it, and it is how the arrangement is advertised in chat without anyone treating it as a grey area.
The edge case is the one everybody already knows about: a reserve offered in exchange for a fee, which is a sale with the auction step removed. That sits next to the rest of the paid dungeon runs in chat, where the product is a service and the price is agreed privately. We are not going to tell you where the line falls, because Blizzard has not published a statement that names hard reserve specifically, and we are not inventing one.
So the honest summary is narrow. The ban on gold auctions is confirmed and quoted everywhere. The status of reserve lists, paid or unpaid, has not been addressed in a developer post we have seen, and no clarification has been attached to the hotfix stream. If one appears, it changes this section and not much else on the realm.
What it does to the auction house
An auction moved gold sideways. The item stayed inside the group, coin went from the buyer to the other members, and nothing new reached the shelf. A reserve moves goods instead: the named item leaves the run with one person, and if it is a BoE or a recipe it usually gets listed. That is a different flow into the market, and it lands on the supply side rather than on the circulating-gold side.
For the person filling a slot the arithmetic also changes. Nobody pays to join, and nobody collects a share at the end, so the run is worth whatever the unreserved drops, the quest turn-ins and the vendor trash come to. That puts it beside the ordinary case for gold earned on dungeon runs, with the best single item already spoken for. On the raid side the same logic has been working itself out separately, and raid loot without gold auctions covers the versions a 40-person group ends up using.
Whether any of this moves prices is open. More BoEs reaching the auction house would push a few listings down; fewer large coin transfers inside groups would thin out the biggest private trades. We have no listing counts for either, and income from BoE drops is the closest thing we track, so treat the direction as reasoning rather than measurement.
Questions
Is a hard reserve the same thing as a gold auction?
No. An auction sold the drop to the highest bidder and split the coin among the group; a hard reserve names the item before the run and hands it to a stated person, with no money changing hands between the participants. The loot rule is similar, the payment is not there, and that is the part the ban was about.
Who actually enforces the reserve?
Nobody, mechanically. The client has no reserve feature, so the arrangement rests on the group leader holding master loot or on the group trusting the advert. If the agreement breaks, the only consequence is reputational, which is why organisers who run reserves regularly tend to use the same name and the same wording every time.
Can a reserve be sold for gold?
Offers of that kind exist in trade chat, and we are describing them rather than recommending them. Blizzard has not published a statement that names hard reserve lists, paid or unpaid, so we have no confirmed rule to quote on it. The plain version with no payment is what the overwhelming majority of advertised runs use.
Does a reserve make a run worth joining as a filler?
It depends on what is reserved. If the list is one or two items, the rest of the loot table is still rolled for by the group, and the run pays what any dungeon run pays. If the list covers most of what the instance is run for, there is little left to roll on, and the time is better spent on a route with a known output.
Sources
- Blizzard's official news feed, where rule changes and hotfix notes for Forever are published — World of Warcraft news.