Why Auction Prices Fall Below the Vendor Floor
A vendor pays a fixed amount for most items, so no seller should ever accept less from a buyer. On the beta auction house that happens constantly, and the reason is not stupidity: it is what testing does to a market that has no reason to hold value.
The vendor price is a floor only if someone uses it
Every item with a sell value has a guaranteed buyer standing in town. That value does not move with demand, does not need a listing and does not wait for a buyer to log in. It is the one price in the game that is always available, which is why what a vendor pays is the sensible starting point for any decision about where stock should go. An auction listing is only worth making when the expected sale price clears that number by enough to cover the charges attached to selling.
On a beta realm that comparison is often ignored. A tester holding stock they will never use has no reason to walk to a vendor, and a listing posted at any price clears the bags just as well. The result is shelves where finished goods and raw stacks sit under the figure a vendor would have handed over without argument. Nothing is broken in the pricing system; the seller simply is not treating coin as something worth keeping.
Deposit and cut are charged whether the sale makes sense or not
Posting is not free. An amount is held when the listing goes up and returned only if the item sells, and a share of the final price is taken out of what reaches the mailbox. Those two charges are separate, and the deposit held on a listing is the one people forget, because it leaves the bag before any buyer exists. A seller who posts a stack three times before it moves has already paid twice for nothing.
Against a vendor sale those charges are pure loss. A vendor hands over the full value immediately, with no hold, no wait and no cut taken on the sale. So an item listed below vendor does not merely lose the difference: it loses the difference plus whatever the posting cost, and loses the deposit again on every relist that expires. A price war run on goods that are already under the floor turns into a slow transfer of coin out of the seller's pocket, and undercutting against the deposit is where that transfer happens.
How a craft ends up losing money
A craft goes negative when the reagents are bought at auction prices and the finished item is sold at or under its vendor value. Both halves are set by other people. Gatherers price raw stacks against their own time, buyers price finished goods against the cheapest listing on the shelf, and nothing connects the two. Working out the cost basis of a craft before posting is the only step that catches the problem, and it has to use the price actually paid for the reagents rather than the price they were worth last week.
Beta adds a second source of cheap stock. A crafter pushing skill produces whatever the trainer list says is green, not what anyone wants, and those items exist as a by-product of the climb. Since materials burned for skill points were spent on the skill rather than on the item, the item feels free, and it gets listed at whatever clears it. Everyone selling the same by-product drives the shelf below the floor, which is why the only crafts worth pricing properly are the ones with a margin over the vendor price wide enough to survive the charges.
What we cannot tell you yet
We have no figures from the beta auction house, and we are not going to invent any. Vendor values, deposit rates and the share taken on a sale are all numbers Blizzard can adjust between builds, and a single patch can change which crafts clear the floor and which do not. Anything we published as a percentage today would be describing one build of a test realm rather than the economy anyone will trade in later.
The mechanics above are stable even when the numbers are not. A deposit is charged at posting, a share is taken at sale, a vendor pays a fixed amount instantly, and a craft is profitable only when the sale price covers the reagents plus both charges. Those relationships are what to carry across from the beta. The specific prices seen there belong to a realm where coin has no future, and they should not be used to plan a budget on a live one.
Questions
Why would anyone sell below what a vendor pays?
Usually because they are not comparing the two. Clearing a bag through a listing takes one trip to the auction house, while vendoring means walking to a merchant, and on a test realm the coin lost does not matter to the seller. It is a sign that the seller has no use for the money rather than a sign that the item is worthless.
Does the deposit come back if the item does not sell?
No. The deposit is held when the listing is created and returned only on a completed sale. An expired auction sends the item back without it, which is why repeated relisting of slow stock is one of the quieter ways to lose coin, and why cheap goods are often better sold to a vendor than posted.
How do I know whether a craft is actually profitable?
Price the reagents at what you paid for them, not at what you hope they are worth, then add the deposit and the share taken on sale, and compare the total with the realistic selling price rather than the highest listing on the shelf. If the result is close to the vendor value of the item, the craft is not a business.
Will the same pattern show up at launch?
Some of it will. Skill-up by-products appear on any realm where crafters are levelling, so cheap finished goods early on are normal. What should not persist is stock listed under its vendor value, because on a realm where coin has a future the seller has a reason to take the guaranteed payment instead.
Sources
- Official patch and hotfix notes, where any change to deposits, the auction cut or vendor values would be published — World of Warcraft news and patch notes.
- Blizzard support, for the general rules covering auction listings and mail delivery — Blizzard Support.